Trade Ideas

Trade Ideas

Trade Ideas is a real-time AI stock scanner with Holly AI signals, and at the top tier it auto-trades a top-three momentum portfolio for you.

80/100Safe BetFree · from $127/moFreemium

If you trade US equities intraday and want one terminal that flags momentum names and can eventually trade them for you, Trade Ideas is actually shipping that. TI Premium costs $178/mo billed annually ($2,136/year) or $254/mo month-to-month, and Money Machine automation is a separate $5,000 purchase on top. Against TradingView or TrendSpider you get far less charting polish for the money — what you're paying for is streaming alerts on every trade and the Holly AI signals with a stop attached to each entry. Buy it for the scanner and signals, not the charts.

Verified 1d ago · liveness 80/100 · cite: rightaichoice.com/tools/trade-ideas

Best for
  • Active US day traders who want a real-time scanner and AI signals in one terminal
  • Momentum traders ready to buy into an automated top-three portfolio
  • Traders already at TradeStation, Brokerage Plus, CenterPoint, or Cobra who can execute in-app
  • Experienced traders who understand short-term risk and want defined stops on every signal
Not ideal for
  • Long-term buy-and-hold investors who don't need intraday scanning
  • Budget-conscious traders — TI Premium is $178/mo billed annually
  • Mac-only users unwilling to run TI Pro through Parallels
Visit Website

IntermediateSame day if you're already a momentum trader: a free account takes just an email with no card, and the Web Dashboard gives you the scanner and Top Lists in the browser immediately. Expect a few sessions to tune scans and get comfortable with TI Pro's dense layout; Money Machine automation is a separate $5,000 purchase to set up after that.Web · DesktopNo public API3.3k viewsVerified 1d ago
Pricing
Free · from $127/mo
FreemiumFree tier6 plans4 hidden costs
Learning curve
Intermediate
Same day if you're already a momentum trader: a free account takes just an email with no card, and the Web Dashboard gives you the scanner and Top Lists in the browser immediately. Expect a few sessions to tune scans and get comfortable with TI Pro's dense layout; Money Machine automation is a separate $5,000 purchase to set up after that.
Runs on
WebDesktop
No public API · 4 integrations
Who it's for
Momentum day trader on TradeStationStrategy tinkerer on TI PremiumTrader testing full automation
Live sentiment
Is Trade Ideas actually worth it?

We scan live Reddit threads, YouTube comments, X posts, G2 reviews and other communities — and hand you an honest verdict in under a minute.

  • Honest verdict, not marketing
  • Real pros & cons from real users
  • Attributed quotes with receipts
Run a free scan

3 free scans · no card needed

Skip it if

Skip Trade Ideas if you want deep charting at a charting-tool price — TI Premium is $178/mo billed annually and you'd be paying for the scanner and Holly signals, not the charts.

The 30-second take
Biggest gripe

Holly AI signals, OddsMaker backtesting and Smart Risk Levels are Premium-only, so the $89/mo billed annually Standard tier leaves out the AI most buyers come for and you'll need $178/mo billed annually to get it.

Price reality

Trade Ideas is priced for committed active traders. TI Standard runs $89/mo billed annually ($1,068/year) or $127/mo month-to-month; TI Premium runs $178/mo billed annually ($2,136/year) or $254/mo monthly, plus $5,000 for Money Machine access. TradingView and TrendSpider cost less for charting, but neither bundles a streaming scanner with AI signals carrying pre-set stops into the same subscription.

In short

Trade Ideas — Trade Ideas is a real-time AI stock scanner with Holly AI signals, and at the top tier it auto-trades a top-three momentum portfolio for you. Best for Active US day traders who want a real-time scanner and AI signals in one terminal, Momentum traders ready to buy into an automated top-three portfolio, Traders already at TradeStation, Brokerage Plus, CenterPoint, or Cobra who can execute in-app. Free to start; paid plans from $127/mo.

No head-to-head comparison for Trade Ideas yet — the alternatives below are the closest matches we list.

What's new in Trade Ideas

Checked yesterday

Across the latest 2 updates: 2 feature updates.

What people actually say about Trade Ideas — is it worth it?

We ran a structured research pass across product reviews, community discussions, and post-purchase forum threads to surface the patterns vendors won't publish themselves. Below: the recurring strengths, the hidden costs people mention most, and the cohort that consistently regrets adopting this tool.

58 mentions across 5 sources (Hacker News, YouTube, Product Hunt, App Store, Lemmy) · researched Oct 14, 2026.

39% positive61% critical

Weighted by the 74 posts each of 5 sources contributed.

Recurring strengths
  • +Real-time scanning across 500+ data points is the genuine core strength traders cite
  • +Money Machine automates a top-three momentum portfolio — no direct TradingView or TC2000 equivalent
  • +Windows-native depth appeals to serious desk traders who want a dense interface
  • +Tiered exposure options (upside, downside, or both) make the automation configurable
  • +Backtesting and Smart Risk Levels support disciplined strategy evaluation
Recurring frustrations
  • −App Store reviews skew 1-star, dominated by pricing opacity and unmet expectations
  • −No short free trial — frustrated users say they must pay before they can properly evaluate
  • −Users report paying for option alerts that never arrive, with weak support follow-up
  • −Chart timeframes reportedly can't be set freely on the free tier, blocking basic evaluation
  • −Bundling stocks, options, and crypto can approach $3,000/year per one App Store estimate
Patterns worth knowing
Pricing is confusing and expensive — multiple tiers for stocks, options, and crypto with no clear bundle
Seen on App Store, YouTube
No real free trial or pre-purchase demo, so buyers can't evaluate before committing
Seen on App Store, YouTube
Affiliate-driven review ecosystem makes impartial opinions hard to find
Seen on YouTube
Learning curve
intermediateProductive in ~Days of setup
Hidden costs people mention
  • • Separate payment required for stocks, options, and crypto — one reviewer estimates ~$3,000/year if bundled
  • • Reported tier confusion where users are asked for $29.99 and then again for $49.99
  • • Money Machine automation at $5,000 is not part of standard subscriptions

Viability Score

80/100
Safe Bet

How well maintained and how widely used is Trade Ideas? Built from what the vendor actually publishes (docs, changelog, tutorials, integrations, pricing), whether the site is live, and how much real users discuss it. How we calculate this

Recent activity
90
Traction
100
Site health
95
User sentiment
42
What the vendor publishes
60

Last calculated: October 2026

How we score →

Key Features

  • Real-time stock scanner with alerts firing on every trade, not candle close
  • Top Lists screeners re-ranking the whole market every 15 seconds
  • 308 stock alerts and 249 screener filters across 500+ data points
  • Holly AI buy signals on big movers, each with an entry and a stop
  • Holly re-entry point when a stopped-out stock turns back
  • TI Wave buy and sell signals overlaid on charts
  • 1st Gen AI Signals with entry and exit points
  • Money Machine 2nd Generation AI automated momentum trading
  • Longs the top 3 momentum stocks at $5K per position
  • Upside, downside, or both exposure selectable in Money Machine
  • Automatic exit when a stock drops out of the top 3
  • OddsMaker backtesting against historical data
  • Smart Risk Levels for position sizing
  • RBI/GBI relative-strength window
  • Real-time paper trading with live market data

About Trade Ideas

FreemiumIntermediateNo APIWeb · Desktop

Trade Ideas is a US equities platform for short-term traders who want software to surface momentum setups and, at the top end, execute them. It has run since 2002 and streams real-time data to fire alerts as trades print rather than on the candle close, plus Top Lists screeners that re-rank the whole market by your filters every 15 seconds. The core products are the real-time scanner (every TI Pro plan), Top Lists screeners, and Holly AI signals, which are part of TI Premium. Holly flags big movers and issues buy signals that each carry an entry and a stop, usually set about 3% from entry, plus a re-entry point if a stock stops out and turns back. Around that sit TI Wave signals overlaid on charts, 1st Gen AI Signals, OddsMaker backtesting, Smart Risk Levels for sizing, the RBI/GBI relative-strength window, customizable Stock Races, real-time paper trading, and an AI Strategy Lab. The headline automation is the Money Machine, the 2nd Generation Trade Ideas AI. It stays long the top three momentum-based stocks at $5K per position, entering when a name enters the top three and exiting only when it drops out, with upside, downside, or both exposure selectable. Money Machine Wave 2 moved it from simulation to real-market automated trading. It is sold as $5,000 exclusive access, separate from the subscription tiers. You can run it in a browser with the Web Dashboard or as the Windows-native TI Pro desktop app (Mac through Parallels). Order execution runs through TradeStation, Brokerage Plus, CenterPoint Securities, and Cobra Trading. A free account takes just an email, no card, and gives live access for a limited time.

Behind the Verdict

Trade Ideas earns its price on one thing: it streams. Alerts fire on every trade rather than the candle close, and Top Lists re-rank the market by your filters every 15 seconds. If your edge depends on catching a move before the crowd, that latency difference is the product. The site claims 308 stock alerts and 249 screener filters across 500+ data points, so the scan depth is genuinely there rather than marketed. The AI layer is the differentiator, with a caveat on how it's sold. Holly AI is the flagship: buy signals on big movers, each with a stop set before you trade (usually about 3% from entry), and a re-entry point if a name stops out and turns back. That structure — risk defined up front — is more honest than a bare signal feed. But Holly, 1st Gen AI Signals, OddsMaker backtesting, Smart Risk Levels, auto trading and Stock Races all sit behind TI Premium at $178/mo billed annually ($2,136/year) or $254/mo month-to-month. TI Standard at $89/mo billed annually ($1,068/year) or $127/mo monthly gives you the scanner, 10 charts, paper trading and TI Wave, but not the AI that most people come for. Budget for Premium or don't bother. Money Machine is the headline and the biggest commitment: $5,000 for exclusive access, long the top three momentum stocks at $5K per position, upside/downside/both selectable. Wave 2 is the material update — it moved the 2nd Generation AI out of simulation and into real-market automated trading. That's real automation, not a paper strategy, and it's not included in any subscription. Where it falls down: the core is Windows-native (Mac users run it through Parallels), so it isn't the modern web-first terminal competitors ship. There is a Web Dashboard for the scanner and Top Lists, which softens that, but the deep charting and multi-window workflows live in TI Pro. Order entry and auto trading only work through TradeStation, Brokerage Plus, CenterPoint Securities or Cobra Trading — if your broker isn't on that list, you're using Trade Ideas for signals and executing elsewhere. The interface is dense and assumes you already understand momentum and short-term risk; beginners will be lost. And the vendor says plainly that it's a publisher and nothing it shows is a recommendation, which is the right disclaimer but also a reminder that the stops and signals are starting points, not guarantees — gaps can blow through a 3% stop. Where it fits: active US momentum traders already on a supported broker who want scanner, signals and optional automation in one place. Where it doesn't: buy-and-hold investors, budget-conscious traders, Mac-only users who won't touch Parallels, and anyone who needs charting depth comparable to TradingView or TrendSpider — Trade Ideas loses that comparison on price and on charts.

Researching Trade Ideas? Get your full AI stack in 60 seconds.

Free, no signup — tell us your goal and get tools matched to your budget & existing stack.

Real-world workflow fit

Concrete scenarios for the personas Trade Ideas actually fits — and what changes day-one when you adopt it.

Momentum day trader on TradeStation

You open TI Pro pre-market, load your saved scans across the 500+ data points, and let alerts fire on every trade as the open prints. When Holly flags a mover with an entry and a stop about 3% away, you size it and send the order to TradeStation from the in-app order panel.

Outcome: Entries and exits come off one screen with risk defined before you click, instead of switching between a scanner, a chart and your broker.

Strategy tinkerer on TI Premium

You build a custom screen with Top Lists, then run it through OddsMaker backtesting against historical data and check sizing with Smart Risk Levels before trading it live in paper trading.

Outcome: You find out whether a scan actually had an edge before committing real capital, and you know your position size when you do.

Trader testing full automation

After a stretch on Premium, you buy Money Machine access, pick upside, downside, or both exposure, and let the 2nd Generation AI hold the top three momentum names at $5K per position, exiting only when a name drops out of the top three.

Outcome: The portfolio rebalances itself against the momentum ranking without you watching every tick — Wave 2 means those are real-market trades, not simulation.

Use Cases

  • Scanning for momentum setups in real time with alerts that fire on every trade
  • Ranking the whole market with Top Lists screeners that refresh every 15 seconds
  • Trading Holly AI signals with a pre-defined stop about 3% from entry
  • Backtesting custom scan strategies with OddsMaker
  • Automating a top-three momentum portfolio with the Money Machine
  • Running paper trades on live data before committing real capital
  • Watching relative strength across names in the RBI/GBI window
  • Executing orders in-app through TradeStation, Brokerage Plus, CenterPoint, or Cobra

Models Under the Hood

Money MachineTI WaveHolly AI

as of 2026-10-16

Limitations

  • The AI is locked to TI Premium: Holly AI signals, 1st Gen AI Signals, OddsMaker backtesting, Smart Risk Levels, auto trading and Stock Races all require the $178/mo billed annually ($2,136/year) or $254/mo month-to-month tier.
  • TI Standard at $89/mo billed annually ($1,068/year) or $127/mo monthly gets you the scanner, 10 charts and TI Wave but not the AI.
  • Money Machine is a separate $5,000 exclusive-access purchase, not part of any subscription.
  • The TI Pro desktop app is Windows-native; Mac users run it through Parallels.
  • In-app order execution and auto trading only work through TradeStation, Brokerage Plus, CenterPoint Securities or Cobra Trading.
  • Holly stops are usually about 3% from entry, but gaps can make a loss bigger, and the vendor states plainly that nothing it shows is a recommendation.

as of 2026-10-22

Verification history

We have re-verified Trade Ideas 23 times since . Each pass re-reads the vendor's own pages and re-checks every listed field against that evidence; passes where nothing had changed are marked as such.

  1. — re-verified summary, description, our verdict, our analysis, pricing model, pricing tiers, features, integrations, who it suits, who should skip it
  2. — re-verified summary, description, our verdict, our analysis, pricing model, pricing tiers, features, integrations, who it suits, who should skip it
  3. — re-verified summary, description, our verdict, our analysis, pricing model, pricing tiers, features, integrations, who it suits, who should skip it
  4. — re-verified summary, description, our verdict, our analysis, pricing model, pricing tiers, features, integrations, who it suits, who should skip it
  5. — re-verified summary, description, our verdict, our analysis, pricing model, pricing tiers, features, integrations, who it suits, who should skip it
  6. — re-verified summary, description, our verdict, our analysis, pricing model, pricing tiers, features, integrations, who it suits, who should skip it

Showing the 6 most recent of 23 verification passes.

Free to cite with attribution — this page re-verifies continuously.

12-month cost

Project the real annual outlay, including the implied monthly cost when only an annual tier is published.

Annual total
Free
Over 12 months
Effective monthly
—
—

Vendor list price only. Add-on usage, seat overages, and contract minimums are surfaced under Hidden costs & gotchas.

Hidden costs & gotchas

What the public pricing page doesn't put in bold. Captured from pricing-page footnotes, contract terms, and recurring complaints.

  • Holly AI signals, OddsMaker backtesting and Smart Risk Levels are Premium-only, so the $89/mo billed annually Standard tier leaves out the AI most buyers come for and you'll need $178/mo billed annually to get it.
  • Month-to-month billing costs more than the annual rate on every tier: $127/mo vs $89/mo billed annually on Standard, and $254/mo vs $178/mo billed annually on Premium.
  • Money Machine is a separate $5,000 exclusive-access purchase on top of your subscription and is not bundled into TI Premium.
  • The free account gives live access only for a limited time, so a long evaluation eventually needs a paid plan.

Where the pricing makes sense

The company stage and team size where Trade Ideas's pricing actually pencils out — and where peers do it cheaper.

Trade Ideas is priced for committed active traders. TI Standard runs $89/mo billed annually ($1,068/year) or $127/mo month-to-month; TI Premium runs $178/mo billed annually ($2,136/year) or $254/mo monthly, plus $5,000 for Money Machine access. TradingView and TrendSpider cost less for charting, but neither bundles a streaming scanner with AI signals carrying pre-set stops into the same subscription.

Setup time & first value

How long it actually takes to get something useful out of Trade Ideas — broken out by persona, not the marketing-page minute.

Same day if you're already a momentum trader: a free account takes just an email with no card, and the Web Dashboard gives you the scanner and Top Lists in the browser immediately. Expect a few sessions to tune scans and get comfortable with TI Pro's dense layout; Money Machine automation is a separate $5,000 purchase to set up after that.

Switching to or from Trade Ideas

How to bring data in from common predecessors and how to get it back out — written for the switcher, not the buyer.

Migrating in
  • →From TradingView: keep TradingView for charting depth and run Trade Ideas alongside for streaming alerts and Holly signals, since the scan engine is the reason to switch.
  • →From TrendSpider: port your watchlists into Trade Ideas scans, then rebuild your alert logic across the 308 stock alerts and 249 screener filters.
Migrating out
  • ↗To TradingView: export your watchlists and rebuild scans as watchlist alerts, accepting that alerts fire on candle close rather than on every trade.
  • ↗To TrendSpider: move your momentum screens across as multi-timeframe scans if charting depth matters more to you than the AI signal layer.

Integrations

TradeStationCenterPoint SecuritiesCobra TradingBrokerage Plus

Resources & Guides

Tutorials & Learning

Tools that pair well with Trade Ideas

Common stack mates teams adopt alongside Trade Ideas, with the specific reason each pairing earns its keep.

Alternatives to Trade Ideas

View all
DealSize.ai

DealSize.ai

Broker-connected trade analytics that pulls your fills automatically and lets you question them in plain English.

FreemiumTry
Magnifi

Magnifi

Magnifi is an AI investing app that links your 401(k), IRA, HSA and brokerage accounts, analyzes them in plain English, and lets you trade commission-free.

FreemiumTry
Kavout

Kavout

AI research agents and Kai Score stock picking across 30+ global markets, in 13 languages.

FreemiumTry

Frequently Asked Questions

Used Trade Ideas? Help shape our editorial sentiment research.